Smooth as Butter – how to make your own

You can’t really go past butter as a delicious luxury on toast, in porridge (true story, you’ve gotta try it) or on some kind of dry biscuit as an adventure snack.  Margarine is, well, it’s just not really food in our books.  Sure, some people choose to avoid dairy altogether, but if you eat dairy go for butter.  Margarine is super highly processed, and whether the fats have been hydrogenated or not, all margarines are a bit too processed and synthetic for our liking.  Butter is pretty nutritious, it has heaps of vitamin A, as well as quite a lot of vitamins D, E and K.  It’s loaded with saturated fat so take it in small quantities but enjoy it when you do.

fresh butter and fruit toast, can't go wrong
fresh butter and fruit sourdough toast, can’t go wrong

A friend recently bought 2L of Jersey cream, mistaking it for milk.  He could only drink so much in his coffee each day so gave me about 400mL.  I’d never made butter before but it worked a treat.  You can make butter with fresh, uncultured cream just fine.  Culturing the cream brings a beautiful depth of flavour and adds the benefits of probiotics to your butter.  You can culture your cream by leaving it in its jar, lid on, on the bench for a few days until it starts to smell a little sour.  If it smells offensive or has mould growing on it throw it out, it’s no good for eating.  This is a bit of an unreliable method.  You can culture your cream by adding a tiny grain of mesophilic culture (just like making yoghurt, read this if you’re uncertain) and incubating it for 12-24 hours.  Another option is to add a small spoonful of fresh yoghurt to your cream and then incubate it.

This is how to make butter:

  • 400mL cream (or more…2L if you want!)
  • tiny weeny sand grain worth of mesophilic culture (optional; can buy from Green Living Australia and other companies)
  • Sea salt

Culture your cream (if you choose to) by adding that tiny bit of mesophilic culture or a teaspoon of fresh yoghurt to room temperature cream and incubate at around 35°C for 12-24 hours until it has thickened and smells pleasantly tangy and sour.  While it is still at room temperature/warm spoon it into your blender or food processor or into a large jar in which the cream fills about 1/3 of the jar.  If you’re using a machine turn it onto a low speed and press go.  If you’re going old school start shaking your jar.  This is the churning process; in a blender or food processor it will usually take less than a minute, by hand up to 30 minutes.  As your churn your cream it will start to change into thicker cream, then chunky thick cream…

chunky thick cream
chunky thick cream

…then it will ‘break’ into yellow butterfat and liquid buttermilk.

broken cream
broken cream

Strain the buttermilk from the butterfat and save it for making pancakes or biscuits, or adding to smoothies for some probiotic goodness.  Next you need to wash the butter to remove as much buttermilk as you can, this will help it keep it from spoiling.  Put your butter into a bowl and pour cold water over it.  Gently knead and press your butter against the walls of the bowl with a spoon and you’ll notice the buttermilk running out.  Pour off the cloudy water and add more cold water; keep kneading until you remove as much buttermilk as you can.

butterfat once the buttermilk has been removed
butterfat once the buttermilk has been removed
rinsing off buttermilk
rinsing off buttermilk

If you like salted butter (let’s be honest, it’s the tastiest butter) add a teaspoon of sea salt, mix through and taste.  Add a little more if it’s to your liking.  Store your butter in an airtight container in the fridge or in your backpack for hiking sustenance.

fresh butter and fruit sourdough. yum!
fresh butter and fruit sourdough. yum!

5 thoughts on “Smooth as Butter – how to make your own

  1. Yum. I had a guernsey cow for some years, before the possums were born, and made all our butter. I managed to pick up a second- (maybe 3rd or 4th) hand milk/cream separator at a clearing sale which fitted the stump in the old dairy on the farm, and I still remember the satisfying feeling I had watching the results pour out the different spouts. Then I used a new-fangled stick food processor and whipped up butter in no time at all. Lovely memories

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s